Donald Trump Jr texted ideas for overturning 2020 election before it was called
Posted On April 9, 2022
Two days after the 2020 presidential election, as votes were still being tallied, Donald Trump‘s eldest son texted then-White House chief of staff Mark Meadows that “we have operational control” to ensure his father would get a second term, with Republican majorities in the US Senate and swing state legislatures, CNN has learned.
In the text, which has not been previously reported, Donald Trump Jr lays out ideas for keeping his father in power by subverting the Electoral College process, according to the message reviewed by CNN.
The text is among records obtained by the House select committee investigating January 6, 2021.
“It’s very simple,” Mr Trump Jr texted to Mr Meadows on November 5, adding later in the same missive: “We have multiple paths … We control them all.”
In a statement to CNN, Mr Trump Jr’s lawyer Alan S. Futerfas said, “After the election, Don received numerous messages from supporters and others. Given the date, this message likely originated from someone else and was forwarded.”
Immediately before his text to Mr Meadows describing multiple paths for challenging the election, Mr Trump Jr texted Mr Meadows the following: “This is what we need to do please read it and please get it to everyone that needs to see it because I’m not sure we’re doing it.”
The November 5 text message outlines a strategy that is nearly identical to what allies of the former President attempted to carry out in the months that followed.
Mr Trump Jr makes specific reference to filing lawsuits and advocating recounts to prevent certain swing states from certifying their results, as well as having a handful of Republican state houses put forward slates of fake “Trump electors.”
If all that failed, according to the Mr Trump Jr text, GOP lawmakers in Congress could simply vote to reinstall Mr Trump as President on January 6.
“We have operational control … Total leverage,” the message reads.
“Moral High Ground POTUS must start 2nd term now.”
The text from Mr Trump Jr is revealing on a number of levels.
It shows how those closest to the former President were already exchanging ideas for how to overturn the election months before the January 6 insurrection – and before all the votes were even counted.
It would be another two days before major news outlets declared Joe Biden the winner on November 7.
The text also adds to a growing body of evidence of how Mr Trump’s inner circle was actively engaged in discussing how to challenge the election results.
On March 28, Judge David Carter, a federal judge in California, said that Mr Trump, along with conservative lawyer John Eastman, launched an “unprecedented” campaign to overturn a democratic election, calling it “a coup in search of a legal theory.”
George Terwilliger, an attorney for Mr Meadows, declined to comment for this story.
A spokesperson for the House select committee declined to comment.
Foreshadowing the Trump campaign strategy
In the weeks following the 2020 election, Mr Trump and his allies eventually filed more than 60 unsuccessful lawsuits in key states, failing to convince the courts that his claims about a stolen election were justified, or uncover any evidence of widespread voter fraud.
They also called for various recounts based on those same unfounded voter fraud claims.
A number of states conducted recounts in the months after the election, though none of them revealed any fraud substantial enough to have changed the outcome of the vote in any state.
While Mr Trump Jr was publicly pushing various voter fraud conspiracy theories and generally casting doubt about the results in states like Pennsylvania and Georgia, his text to Mr Meadows reveals there were other ideas being discussed privately.
Specifically, Mr Trump Jr previews a strategy to supplant authentic electors with fake Republican electors in a handful of states.
That plan was eventually orchestrated and carried out by allies of the former President, and overseen by his then-attorney Rudy Giuliani.
In his text to Mr Meadows, Mr Trump Jr identifies two key dates in December that serve as deadlines for states to certify their electoral results and compel Congress to accept them.
Though the dates are largely ceremonial, in his text Mr Trump Jr appears to point to them as potential weaknesses to be exploited by casting doubt on the legitimacy of the election results.
Mr Trump Jr’s November 5 text to Mr Meadows came as similar notions of faithless electors were starting to percolate publicly on conservative social media.
Mr Trump Jr sent the text to Mr Meadows at 12.51 p.m., just minutes after conservative radio host Mark Levin had tweeted a similar idea and suggested state legislatures have final say on electors.
If secretaries of state were unable to certify the results, Mr Trump Jr argues in his text to Mr Meadows that they should press their advantage by having Republican-controlled state assemblies “step in” and put forward separate slates of “Trump electors,” he writes.
“Republicans control Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, North Carolina etc we get Trump electors,” Mr Trump Jr adds.
Mr Trump Jr’s text, however, refers to an untested legal theory that state houses are the ultimate authority in elections and can intervene to put forward a different slate of electors than those chosen by the voters, when in reality this is a ceremonial process and the outcome is essentially a foregone conclusion.
The Justice Department and the House committee are both investigating the fake electors plot within the context of what unfolded on January 6 and Trump’s broader effort to overturn the election.
The strategy floated by Mr Trump Jr is similar to what was outlined by former Texas Governor and Trump Energy Secretary Rick Perry, who texted Meadows on November 4 suggesting three state legislatures ignore the will of their voters and deliver their states’ electors to Mr Trump.
“HERE’s an AGRESSIVE (sic) STRATEGY: Why can t (sic) the states of GA NC PENN and other R controlled state houses declare this is BS (where conflicts and election not called that night) and just send their own electors to vote and have it go to the SCOTUS,” Mr Perry’s text message read.
A spokesman for Mr Perry told CNN at the time that the former Energy secretary denies being the author of the text.
However, multiple people who know Mr Perry previously confirmed to CNN that the phone number the committee has associated with that text message is Mr Perry’s number.
Capitol fenced off after day of chaos
Mr Trump Jr also texts Mr Meadows that Congress could intervene on January 6 and overturn the will of voters if, for some reason, they were unable to secure enough electoral votes to tip the outcome in Mr Trump’s favour using the state-based strategy.
That option, according to Mr Trump Jr’s text, involves a scenario where neither Mr Biden nor Mr Trump have enough electoral votes to be declared a winner, prompting the House of Representatives to vote by state party delegation, with each state getting one vote.
“Republicans control 28 states Democrats 22 states,” Mr Trump Jr texts.
“We either have a vote WE control and WE win OR it gets kicked to Congress 6 January 2021,” he texts Mr Meadows.
In a series of memos in early January, conservative lawyer John Eastman proposed a variation of that idea.
Dr Eastman’s memo laid out a six-step plan for Vice President Mike Pence to overturn the election for Mr Trump, which included throwing out the results in seven states because they allegedly had competing electors.
In fact, no state had actually put forward an alternate slate of electors – there were merely Mr Trump allies claiming without any authority to be electors.
Dr Eastman, who has been subpoenaed by the House select committee and is fighting to keep some of his records secret from investigators, was accused by Mr Carter of likely engaging in a criminal conspiracy with Mr Trump to overturn the election.
“Dr Eastman has an unblemished record as an attorney and respectfully disagrees with the judge’s findings,” his attorney Charles Burnham said in response to the judge’s ruling.
Trump Jr pushes Meadows to fire Wray and install loyalist at FBI
Mr Trump Jr ends his November 5 text by calling for a litany of personnel moves to solidify his father’s control over the government by putting loyalists in key jobs and initiate investigations into the Biden family.
“Fire Wray; Fire Fauci,” he texts, referring to FBI Director Christopher Wray and White House coronavirus adviser Anthony Fauci.
Mr Trump Jr then proposes making former acting Director of National Intelligence Ric Grenell interim head of the FBI and having then-Attorney General Bill Barr “select Special prosecutor on HardDrivefromHell Biden crime family.”
As Mr Trump refused to concede in the days and weeks after the 2020 election, rumours swirled that he was still considering firing Mr Wray, along with several other top officials with whom he had grown frustrated.
Mr Trump and his allies sharply criticised Mr Wray for failing to produce information that they claimed would be harmful to the President’s political enemies, including Mr Biden.
CNN previously reported that the prospect of Mr Trump firing Mr Wray hung over the FBI for weeks, dating to before Election Day.
While Mr Wray remains in his post and Mr Barr resigned in mid-December 2020 without naming a special prosecutor to investigate the Bidens, Mr Trump Jr’s text underscores just how precarious the situation at DOJ was in the immediate aftermath of the election.
The same is true for Mr Trump Jr’s recommendation that Meadows replace Mr Wray with Mr Grenell, someone who not only lacked the usual qualifications to lead the FBI but also had a proven track record of doing the former President’s bidding.
After serving a controversial three-month stint as Mr Trump’s acting intel chief, Mr Grenell hit the campaign trail in late 2020 to help promote Mr Trump’s unfounded claims of widespread voter fraud and support his legal challenges in a key swing state: Nevada.
On November 5, Mr Biden held a slim lead over Mr Trump in Nevada but appeared poised to win the state’s six electoral votes.
That same day, Mr Grenell and Mr Trump campaign officials announced they were filing a new lawsuit to “stop the counting of illegal votes” but provided no evidence to support their claims of rampant fraud.